Ah, don't get me wrong. I do enjoy his show on occasion (not this past year though and I'll get to that) and I do applaud him for helping bring rock and roll back to the forfront the best he can. It's only the first year and this past year that I have found really disappointing. Good Points:He's playing songs that have been slowly become endangered due to the disappearence of oldies radio and the really good ones at that. Before his show, I hadn't heard Talk Talk or Psychotic Reaction on free radio over the airwaves in close to 15 years. I even called one time to request one of those songs and they claimed they didn't have it. I asked them why not, and they claimed that they were too harsh for their station. What? Anyway, he also plays old songs that never made it to the radio (at least in the States) such as Midnight To Six Man or I Can Only Give You Everything. What else....He made the Ramones, Iggy Pop (and Stooges), MC5, New York Dolls, Sex Pistols, Dead Boys, early Clash, Damned legitimate acts. In that I mean, they are no longer just part of the KROQ ghetto. Sure, a lot more meatheads now know who they are, but in the long run, just taking the time to promote their existence means a lot. And maybe the bad qualities are out numbered by the good but that first year was horrid compared to others, simply for the fact that he didn't take the time to present a well rounded history of what came before for the last 20 years prior to his show. It would have been nice to hear Voxx bands during the first year instead of Enuff Z'nuff or Cotton Mather. And I don't like the fact they he says he'd rather promote bands instead of singer songwriters, but then why does he have Graham Parker (or something similar). Well at least his choices are better than what the stations usually play when he's show is not on. As for this year, he should have let some of his Sirius Hosts guest host for the national show and present some fresh shows while he's been on tour instead of just repeating past themes with only "Coolest Song In the World This Week" be the only new feature (plus incorporating other new songs into the shows taking place of last year's new songs). And the new bands he's been promoting thIs past few months almost stink of favoritism. I won't say payola because that's probably not true at all, and I don't mean bands on Wicked Cool, either (even though that REALLY doesn't look good). No, I mean promoting his BOSS's band, Cheap Trick, Green Day, and others who don't need his help, plus some of the weak choices pitched his way, such as this Care Bears on Fire, or Tinted Windows (with a Samshing Pumkin and a Hanson Brother no less. The Noisettes really aren't that good either. Last year and earlier this year, he had bands like the Urges, Satteliters, Thee Exciters, some others I can't recall at the moment on his show and I feel those are the bands that truly deserve his help, and he actually did a lot more of that during 2004-2007 but it's slowly drifting back to what his first year was like. And that's why I feel it's a half ass job these days. I also think it's a big slap in the face of garage rock that he didn't take the time to mention the passing of Lux Interior. He did just as much and probably more to promote the gospel of garage rock. He deserved a tribute.
You are right though. He should be commended for giving this genre a chance to be heard and giving rock a good shot in the arm that it deserves.
And I do wish that some of the others on here who say they don't like him give a good reason why instead of just saying they don't like him or what he appears to be ( a corporate fraud? Maybe. I don't think so. He's gotta pay the bills but I wish he wouldn't do it promoting the new U-2 album or Elvis Costello).