Wow, I hardly know where to start with what is fundamentally wrong with this article.
what a long long stretch this writer has made to prove a thesis. Always a danger when intellectuals and writers try to define musical expression. No?
""Now deified as arguably punk's most important individual, Malcolm McLaren,""
""US punk "godmother" Patti Smith""
Not hard to find a quote from Mr Lydon refuting both these claims.
I think most would prefer an article on the French punk scene and a list of bands to check out rather than this.
It supposes that punk gets it's meaning from politics. (rather than from the expression of teenagers feeling both alienated and horny)
To quote Marshall McLuhan "the Medium IS the message".
I am sure most punk rock fans in France would agree.